Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Scotland Decides

It looks like a really close independence vote in Scotland. I guess I would've come down on the 'No' side, mainly because of the currency issues. If Scotland keeps the pound, it seems that Scotland's economy is still ruled by London bankers, and it loses what little ability it had to control them. But the future is hard to figure out -- maybe they don't keep the pound, or any one of dozens of considerations overrides that. I'm glad I don't have to make these decisions.

My own postcolonial attachments to the idea of independence from England make it hard for me to be a 'No' supporter. As the American-born child of Bengali parents, I'm at the intersection of two spectacular stories of throwing off English rule. The American story is familiar, but the Indian story may be even better. Over centuries of being ruled by well-educated Englishmen, famines that killed millions were common in India. In the Bengal famine of the early 1940s, Churchill shipped the grain out of the Bengali countryside to fortify Calcutta against a Japanese siege that never came, starving millions of Bengali villagers. (Leo Amery, the British Secretary of State for India, recalls Churchill saying, 'I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion'.) Then after India becomes an independent democracy, famines that kill millions are a thing of the past. When severe drought hit Maharastra in 1972, the government responded to popular pressure for relief, and mass starvation was avoided. The US and Indian success story is basically the success story of democracy -- the people may not be geniuses, but they'll stop you from starving them. I guess if Scotland were to lose all democratic control over its monetary policy, the democratic lessons of America and India might actually apply against independence.

To a utilitarian like me, political systems are broadly like sewer systems. Their proper functioning is tremendously important to human life, and sometimes it's best to build your identity around them. Seriously, with the sewers. If your regime won't let you ever build sewers, becoming a violent sewer revolutionary and murdering people who won't let you do what's needed to build them may be better than letting millions die in endless cholera epidemics. But it's best for the structure of political authority and your identity to come apart if sticking them together doesn't achieve good consequences.

There's all kinds of cool arguments I've heard for independence, including my friend Alfred's argument that an independent Scotland could fill its underpopulated areas with enterprising immigrants (he pointed at me and said "we need more clever fuckers like you!"). Maybe some of these arguments point to systematic reasons why Scottish nationalism is a force for good. It's not impossible. Indian nationalism a hundred years ago was well aligned with the betterment of India, and very likely humanity as a whole. But if that's true of Scotland now, it's not something I can clearly see.

Scotland will always be the home of my favorite British things. There's MacPherson's Farewell, and Fear a Bhata, and the Loch Tay Boat Song. There's David Hume, and more recently, my buddy Aidan McGlynn versus this English knowledge-first thing that looks more useless on issues the better I understand them. There's the beauty of Edinburgh and the Highlands and girls with skin like milk and hair like fire. And I expect them to remain just as beautiful no matter what Scottish voters chose.

6 comments:

nadiya said...

Really informative blog for all people. Thanks for sharing it.
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
Spoken English in Chennai
Data Analytics Courses in Chennai
IELTS Coaching centre in Chennai
Japanese Language Classes in Chennai
TOEFL Classes in Chennai
Spoken English Classes in Tambaram
Spoken English Classes in Anna Nagar

technorok said...

Hi, I do think this is a great blog. I stumbledupon it ;) I am going to come back yet again since I saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the best way to change, education may you be rich and continue to help others.

nisha said...

The blog is explained clearly.concepts are represented very neatly.

Data Science Training Course In Chennai | Data Science Training Course In Anna Nagar | Data Science Training Course In OMR | Data Science Training Course In Porur | Data Science Training Course In Tambaram | Data Science Training Course In Velachery


Jhon Michael said...

Freelance maintenance technicians also benefit from establishing relationships with multiple clients. Working as a freelancer, you’ll gain employment experience with a variety of businesses, boosting your overall skill set and providing you with more work opportunities in the future.

maintenance technician

Business Analytics Course said...

I have voiced some of the posts on your website now, and I really like your blogging style. I added it to my list of favorite blogging sites and will be back soon ...

Business Analytics Course in Bangalore

Data Analytics Course said...

I will very much appreciate the writer's choice for choosing this excellent article suitable for my topic. Here is a detailed description of the topic of the article that helped me the most.

Data Analytics Course in Bangalore